Efficient Markets Require Perfect Information

Wholesale versus Retail

In 1993, the SEC had drunk the value-added koolaid popular among beltway bandits of the era. The story went that digital data cost a lot of money to produce and was only of interest to specialized audiences, such as Wall Street fatcats. Why should the government pay good money to serve these specialized needs? Instead, the feds should give all their data to retail information providers who would "add value," somehow making the data more palatable.

Jamie Love, Ralph Nader's designated raider on Internet matters wasn't buying it and was demanding that the SEC put their EDGAR database on the Internet for free access by all. The SEC dug their heals in and told their congressional oversight committee that it would cost millions and millions of dollars to put EDGAR online, and that the Internet didn't make sense because it didn't as they so tactfully put it "have the right kind of people." What they meant was that the net was just a few computer science researchers on a DoD research project. Ha!

The Right Kind of People

After the SEC advanced their theory as to why EDGAR shouldn't go on-line, the congressional overseers decided they'd get a reality check. They called in the Internet Multicasting Service, the predecessor to Public.Resource.Org, and asked us what we thought about all this. Well, we told them we thought that the American people were the right kind of people and what sense did it make to have our stock markets function on less-than-perfect information?

With a donated computer from Eric Schmidt at Sun Microsystems and a National Science Foundation grant arranged by Steve Wolff to let us buy the data, Brewster Kahle donated WAIS software for full-text searches, the newfangled web thing seemed like a reasonable user interface, and we were off and running!

Two years later, with a little maneuvering and some bombast, the SEC was happily running the service themselves!

PAPER TRAIL

09.11.95
thumbnail of documentartwork
LOANED
Loaner Agreement with the SEC
pdf
08.31.95
thumbnail of document
RECEIVED
Dear Mr. Malamud
pdf
08.16.95
thumbnail of document
WIRED
Markey Aplauds SEC Initiative
pdf
07.31.95
thumbnail of document
SURFED
EDGAR Access Statistics
pdf
12.15.93
thumbnail of document
PURCHASED
Cost for NEXIS Access to Public Docs
pdf
12.10.93
thumbnail of document
DELIVERED
Dear Mr. Duncan
pdf
12.08.93
thumbnail of document
DEMANDED
To the Honorable Arthur Levitt, Jr. - WTF?
pdf
12.08.93
thumbnail of document
DEMANDED
To the Honorable James J. Duderstadt - A CLM?
pdf
07.07.93
thumbnail of document
SUBMITTED
Attention: Proposal Processing Unit
pdf

TRACKBACK

boingboing
S.E.C. Seeks to Keep Free Internet Service — New York Times August 16, 1995
boingboing
An Internet Access to S.E.C. Filings to End Oct. 1 — New York Times August 12, 1995
boingboing
Same-Day Internet Access to S.E.C. Filings — New York Times May 1, 1995
boingboing
Group to Widen Access To Federal Data Bases — New York Times December 23, 1994
boingboing
boingboing
Internet Users Get Access To S.E.C. Filings Fee-Free — New York Times January 17, 1994
boingboing
Plan Opens More Data To Public — New York Times October 22, 1993
Mappa.Mundi Icon
The Importance of Being EDGAR — Mappa.Mundi Magazine September 15, 1999
icon
Private Entrepreneurship for the Public Good — Institute for Local Self-Reliance June 30, 1998